Home » Recipes » Holidays » Peanut Butter and Jelly Hearts
| |

Peanut Butter and Jelly Hearts

Perfect after school, lunchbox or Valentine's Day party treat!

If you are looking for a special treat for your children on Valentine’s Day look no further than Peanut Butter and Jelly Hearts Sandwich.  I can’t claim this as an original but I will say that I made them for my sons class party at school and they were a huge hit!  You could substitute with any nut butter, nutella or cream cheese to avoid nut allergies if taking them to school.  They would also make a great after school or lunchbox treat for Valentine’s Day too! Enjoy!

PBJ Hearts

Print Recipe
Prep Time:20 minutes
Total Time:20 minutes


  • 1- inch and 3-inch heart-shaped cookie cutters
  • 2 slices bread
  • 1 tablespoon Creamy Peanut Butter
  • 1 tablespoon Strawberry Jelly


  • Cut out both slices of bread with the 3" heart cookie cutter. Cut a 1" heart shape from the center of one slice of bread; discard scraps.
  • SPREAD the solid heart bread slice with peanut butter.
  • Top with cut heart bread slice and fill small heart opening with jelly.
Servings: 10
Author: Jif.com

Your kids will love these Peanut Butter and Jelly Hearts Sandwich! What a special surprise for them!

Thanks to my friend Jamie York for sharing this with me.

Be sure to check out these Valentine’s Day posts:

Planning a frugal Valentine’s Day

Valentine’s Day Treat Box Ideas

Batman Valentine Exchange Box

Handstamped Valentine Cards

Heart Photo Craft Using Cupcake Wrappers

How to Make a Candy Vase

Candy Cane Hearts

How to make a “candy bar cake”

Frugal Handmade Valentine’s

Check out some of our 3 Ingredient Cookie and Treat Recipes

3 INGREDIENT CHOCOLATE FUDGE – You can’t get any easier than 3 ingredient chocolate fudge!  This is the easiest recipe I have ever seen before for Chocolate Fudge and it doesn’t require a candy thermometer.

THREE INGREDIENT PEANUT BUTTER COOKIES – Three ingredient peanut butter cookies are my go to cookie recipe for an easy peanut butter cookie.

COCOA MARSHMALLOW TREATS – Cocoa Marshmallow Treats are such a fun and an inventive way to make a kid friendly dessert!

Mallow Treat Bars – This is a great kid-friendly recipe that kids of all ages can assist in making.

Gluten Free Crispy Cocoa Rice Treats – This Gluten Free Crispy Cocoa Rice Treats recipe is amazing and so easy to prepare! They taste so good that you can’t tell they are gluten free.

FROZEN GRAHAM CRACKER TREATS – These Frozen Graham Cracker Treats are perfect for summer. I made these easy dessert treats in less than ten minutes.

MICROWAVE CHOCOLATE HAZELNUT S’MORES – Too cold for S’mores? Think again! Check out this easy and delicious recipe for Microwave Chocolate Hazelnut S’Mores!

Interested in Freezer Cooking?

We have a Freezer Cooking 101 Series that you may enjoy!

Stockpiling Moms can be found in all your favorite places. Hop on over to Instagram and follow the fun. We love posting memes, family fun, travel, and whatever we are feeling that day. Pinterest is also an amazing place to visit Stockpiling Moms. This is where you can pin all your favorite articles from our Food, Travel & Lifestyle Blog.

Similar Posts


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.